Skip to main content

Empowering Minds: The Incredible Impact of Giving Students Choices in English Language Arts



Education is a voyage of discovery, a journey to unlock the vast world of knowledge, and it's a journey best undertaken with a sense of autonomy and empowerment. In the realm of English Language Arts (ELA), where students dive into the wonders of literature, language, and storytelling, the power of choice takes on a transformative role. It's a tool that not only engages young minds but also aligns perfectly with what we know about brain and learning research.


The Science Behind the Choice


Recent studies in education psychology have revealed the profound impact of student choice on motivation, engagement, and ultimately, learning. When students have the opportunity to make choices about their learning, their brains light up with enthusiasm. This is not just a metaphorical expression; it's a neurological reality. The brain's reward centers, such as the ventral striatum, become more active when students are allowed to make choices. This heightened engagement is associated with a release of dopamine, the "feel-good" neurotransmitter.


Moreover, learning through choice stimulates the prefrontal cortex, which plays a key role in decision-making, problem-solving, and critical thinking. As students grapple with choices, they are exercising their cognitive muscles, honing their executive functions, and becoming more adept learners.


Student choice and autonomy are not merely educational buzzwords; they are the cornerstones of fostering a learning environment that truly motivates and engages students. When students have the agency to make decisions about their learning, whether it's choosing what to study, how to study, or how to demonstrate their understanding, a powerful transformation occurs. They become active participants in their education, rather than passive recipients. This shift in roles is fundamental in kindling motivation. Research in education psychology consistently shows that when students have the autonomy to make choices about their learning, their intrinsic motivation soars. They feel a sense of ownership over their education, which translates into a genuine desire to explore, learn, and excel.


Furthermore, the link between student choice, autonomy, and achievement is indisputable. When students are personally invested in their learning, they are more likely to set and pursue meaningful goals. This intrinsic motivation translates into a powerful driver for achievement. They are not simply aiming for a grade; they are pursuing mastery and understanding. Research also highlights that students who have a say in their learning processes tend to exhibit better retention of information, improved problem-solving skills, and more effective critical thinking abilities. In essence, student choice and autonomy are catalysts for engagement and achievement because they transform students from passive learners into active, enthusiastic seekers of knowledge and skill.


The ELA Classroom: A Haven for Choice


Now, let's translate this science into the vibrant landscape of the ELA classroom. Imagine a space where students aren't passive recipients of knowledge but active participants in their learning journey. This is precisely where choice boards come into play. These versatile tools offer students the opportunity to take charge of their learning, explore their interests, and engage with content in ways that resonate with them personally.


A choice board is a treasure trove of options. It provides students with the autonomy to select the materials and tasks that pique their curiosity. It's a roadmap to learning that celebrates individuality and diverse learning styles.


The Power of Choice Boards


In the world of ELA, where textual analysis, comprehension, and literary exploration are paramount, choice boards can be a game-changer. Take, for instance, this choice board designed to help students analyze the text structure of suspense stories. It offers students a selection of intriguing stories, each with its unique flavor of mystery and tension.


"The Lady, or the Tiger" by Frank R. Stockton, "The Cask of Amontillado" by Edgar Allan Poe, "The Open Window" by Saki, "Lamb to the Slaughter" by Roald Dahl, and "His Face All Red" by E.M. Carroll, written like a graphic short story, are all on the menu.


The Transformative Journey of Choice


As students choose their path through this choice board, they are embarking on a transformative journey. They're not merely analyzing text structure; they're uncovering the secrets of suspense, unraveling the nuances of foreshadowing, and dissecting the intricacies of plot, all through stories that intrigue them.

The beauty of the choice board is that it accommodates diverse learning approaches. Literature circles offer collaborative exploration, with students pairing up or forming groups to read and discuss their chosen stories. For the independent souls, it's a chance to work solo and then engage in a whole-class discussion. The possibilities are as diverse as the students themselves.


Learning Beyond the Bell


But the journey doesn't end with textual analysis. The power of choice extends to presentations, discussions, and a deeper exploration of commonalities and differences in the stories. It's an opportunity to think critically, to reflect, and to share insights with peers.


And, of course, it's a lot of fun. In the journey to master language arts standards, who said it had to be boring? This choice board ignites a spark of enthusiasm, making standards-based teaching and learning a delightful adventure.



In the world of education, the power of choice is a beacon that lights the way for learners. It is the essence of empowerment, the cornerstone of engagement, and the catalyst for lasting love for the magic of words and stories. Join us in celebrating this journey, where choice and learning intertwine to create brighter, more engaged minds.


Follow me,  Faulkner English , on TPT for freebies and resources.

A Doll's House After Reading Choice Board

Popular posts from this blog

Unlocking Creative Brilliance with Digital Magnetic Poetry: Teach Syntax, Diction, and Tone

Originally published 1/14/2009.  Updated 11/4/2023 The possibilities are infinite--ish when you use online magnets to get creative. No refrigerator necessary. Free online kits here . Poetry, with its mesmerizing ability to encapsulate emotions, stories, and ideas within the boundaries of words, is a true art form. But there's a particular type of poetry that holds a special place in my heart—the kind that challenges our traditional understanding of language and syntax. I'm talking about magnetic poetry, the quirky, wordplay-filled realm where creativity knows no bounds. I love this type of poetry! It really makes me think in a different syntax, playing with a strange juxtaposition of words. Often, I use this format when I am bored or if I have NO IDEA what I want to write about! The beauty of magnetic poetry lies in its simplicity and boundless potential for creativity. It's an art form where words become movable puzzle pieces, waiting to be rearranged into poetic masterpi...

A Book Review of Sark's (2008) Juicy Pens Thirsty Paper: Gifting the World with Your Words and Stories and Creating the Time and Energy to Actually Do It

A Book Review of Juicy Pens Thirsty Paper: Gifting the World with Your Words and Stories and Creating the Time and Energy to Actually Do It by Sark.  Three Rivers press, 2008. 185 pages. $18.95.             When I first discovered Sark, I was at once inspired, envious, and critical. I remember sitting on my best friend’s bed, covered in its usual tangle of sarongs and tapestries rather than real bed clothes, growing more incredulous as I flipped each page of Succulent Wild Woman (1997).   What kind of new-age hippie crap was this?   Someone had gotten paid to write this ?   These doodles and handwritten pages were worthy of my ultimate goal, that pinnacle of success, PUBLICATION?   But each spunky drawing and passage motivated me to continue my own writing.   Sark wrote the way I wrote, turning letters to friends into artwork, and if she could get paid for it then I could.     ...

What is Working Memory?

How Does The Brain Work? If I could answer that question, I could probably be cooling my heels on a nice island somewhere, mimosa in hand,  Instead, I am left to read research and theories about how the brain (and reading) operates.  One can dream, though..... For years, researchers delineated memory into two types:  short term and long term.  More recently, after the advent of LaBerge and Samuels Automaticity Theory (1974) and Perfetti's Verbal Efficiency Theory (1988), this construct was re-imagined as working memory --which adds the dimension of processing to the function of storage ( Daneman & Carpenter , 1980).  As they explain, "Working memory is assumed to have processing as well as storage functions; it serves as the site for executing processes and for storing the products of these processes" (p. 450).  Working memory is active rather than passive.   Tanabe , Azumi , Osaka, & Naoyuki (2009) explain that workin...